Showing posts with label mass affluent. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mass affluent. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 13, 2013

Will The Power of Mobile Make Bank Branches Disappear?


The high rate of mobile banking penetration at Chase Bank, Bank of America and recently introduced direct banks such as Simple, GoBank, Bluebird and Moven could provide a significant business advantage as digital channels tend to build loyalty and provide the opportunity to reduce costs through transaction migration. 


A recent report from Bain & Company entitled, 'Customer Loyalty in Retail Banking' found that mobile banking is more likely to increase a customer's likelihood of recommending the bank than any other channel interaction and that features such as remote deposit and even the ability to check a balance impact loyalty. The research also found that once customers moved to mobile, roughly half stated they made fewer visits to the branch which can lower costs.

Digital Delight


As mobile banking use increases, banks have the opportunity to 'delight' customers with new applications and functionality. For instance, while remote deposit capture still represents just a small percentage of branch and ATM transactions (as shown by the size of the circles below), it is by far the most likely to 'wow' the customer (64%) and provide the opportunity to recommend the bank. 

Interestingly, even routine mobile transactions such as checking a balance or transferring between accounts has a likelihood to delight (44%) and is a strong influence on loyalty according to the Bain study.

Subscribe to Bank Marketing Strategies

The delight with the mobile channel increases with use as well, with higher frequency mobile transactors being more likely to recommend their bank regardless of age category or type of institution. It was found that younger customers (age 25-35) were more likely to illustrate stronger loyalty (as measured by Net Promoter Score) based on mobile and that the larger and direct banks had the largest lift in NPS score between mobile and non-mobile users as shown below.

This disparity in loyalty between the larger and smaller organizations and for direct banks is believed to be the result of more advanced functionality by the largest players such as Chase, Bank of America, U.S. Bank, PNC, Wells Fargo and the direct players.
As shown above, for retail bankers battling for new customers and the loyalty of existing customers, digital channels can be a powerful tool for building loyalty and referral business. However, digital advantages are short-lived as mobile development is getting greater emphasis and differentiation is short-lived. For instance, while remote deposits may still be a differentiator in some markets, they are quickly becoming table stakes in the competition for the mobile customer. But the potential loyalty of a satisfied mobile customer can't be disputed.

Power of Premium Apps


While doing the mobile basics is important, the key is to continually develop innovative applications that appeal to the mass market while building premium tools for the affluent customer who is more demanding. This could include personal financial management (PFM) applications as well as tools that integrate both online and offline advisory capabilities.

The importance of developing premium applications is highlighted by the finding that moving an affluent or mass affluent customer from being either unsatisfied or 'passive' to being a 'promoter' is worth five times more than converting a mass market customer. This is because an affluent customer who is loyal has more products with the bank as well as having the tendency to recommend their bank to other affluent friends. In fact, Bain estimates that converting just 5,000 affluent customer from being passive or a distractor to being a promoter could generate $25 million in lifetime net present value.

Moving From Physical to Digital


While not being a 1:1 conversion, mobile banking can divert large volumes of high-frequency routine transactions, reducing branch visits and providing the springboard for branch redesign and reduced costs (see previous BMS post 'Banks Transforming Branch Networks to Improve Efficiencies'). And, as shown above, these same routine branch-based transactions either don't have a big impact on loyalty or are more prone to annoy customers than mobile transactions.

The benefit of moving from the physical to digital channels is more acute in the U.S. than any other developed country due to our dependence on the brick-and-mortar facility. According to the study, the average customer in the U.S. visits the branch more often than in other countries and 90% of the transactions done in a branch are considered routine (cashing checks, making deposits, checking balances, etc.).
According to the Bain study, once customers turn to mobile channels, roughly half made fewer visits to a branch: 29% of the U.S. mobile converts reported making between one-tenth and one-half fewer visits, while 18% said they reduced their number of visits by half or more. 

This movement from the physical to digital can have an immediate bottom line impact. According to research conducted by Diebold, a transaction that costs $4.25 in a branch would cost $2.40 through a call center and only $.20 online. Moving the customer transaction to the mobile channel would reduce the cost to $.08. This transition obviously would also allow banks to reconfigure branches and remove expensive human interaction or allow for the closing of branches altogether.
This change in branch design can go beyond just the reduction of costs to also improve the overall customer experience according to Bain due to shorter wait times, more consistent service, etc. For instance, Coastal Federal Credit Union does not employ a single teller behind the counter at its 15 branches and Boeing Employees' Credit Union has employed a 'teller-less' branch layout for years, leveraging online and mobile banking combined with multiple teller machines. This reduces the required footprint of branches, extends hours of operation and has led to market leading customer satisfaction scores.

The Disappearance of Branches


Even with the rapid acceptance of mobile and online banking and the business rationale for moving more customers to digital channels, branches will not disappear overnight, especially in the U.S. But, as banks continuously improve their mobile banking applications, encourage customer to try these new capabilities, and provide experiential incentives to move their routine (and non-routine) transactions to less costly and potentially easier interactions, branches will move from center stage to being part of a more integrated omnichannel experience as illustrated below.

Instead of processing thousands of basic transactions, branches in the future will be more similar to Apple stores, being product showrooms, serving as sales centers and locations to provide expert 1:1 advice. Even these functions may move to digital video terminals in the future as consumers become more comfortable with technology.
To make the transition, digital channels need to be more intuitive and convenient while providing financial and non-financial benefits. Execution and ease of use will be critical and the use of 'big data' for the benefit of the customer will be expected. 

We are already seeing this type of customer focus with new offerings from Simple, GoBank and Moven, where financial management tools are not added to a mobile application but integrated in the offerings. This type of integration is also evident overseas with innovative banks such as Commonwealth Bank of Australia, Fidor Bank in the Netherlands and U.K.'s First Direct.

Marketing Disconnect?


Given all of the benefits discussed around moving more customers from the physical branch to the mobile and online device, you would expect marketing to view this channel shift objective as one of their primary goals in 2013. 

Unfortunately, based on the most recent 2013 State of Bank and Credit Union Marketing report just released by The Financial Brand, the focus on online and mobile banking adoption falls to sixth on the list of priorities after loan growth, cross-selling, new customer acquisition, brand development and attracting a younger customer.
Part of the challenge may be that marketers could believe that the responsibility for mobile banking adoption falls into the lap of the applications developer or another person at the institution, but research shows that adoption of mobile is really everyone's responsibility and that all channels should be used for promoting the benefits of the mobile channel (see recent BMS post entitled, Nine Ways Marketing Can Help Acquire Mobile Banking Customers).

Even though financial marketers say 'loan growth' is their most important strategic goal for 2013, they rank 'mobile banking solutions' as the most critical product/service to push this year . . . followed by loans.



So, will the emphasis on promoting mobile and the power of mobile make branches disappear? Time will tell, but with the loyalty and cost advantages of digital channels, traditional banks will need to move quickly to keep pace with the innovations being developed by the new branch-less players who are quickly entering the financial services battlefield.


Additional Resources

2013 State of Bank and Credit Union Marketing - The Financial Brand (February 2013)

Customer Loyalty In Retail Banking: Global Edition - Bain & Company (December 2012)

Banking Loyalty Profile: United States - Bain & Company (December 2012)

How Many Mobile Users Does Citibank Have? - Bank Innovation (February 2013)

The Digital Challenge to Retail Banks - Bain & Company (October 2012)

Monday, November 5, 2012

The Mass Affluent: An Elusive Bank Target


While targeted by every bank, mass affluent households are difficult for bank marketers to reach. They have a distinct lifestyle from the rest of the nation in terms of media consumption, technology use, financial attitudes and preferences for financial products and services.
 



Representing a sweet spot between the mass market and affluent segment, the mass affluent segment is not homogeneous, but a diverse array of micro segments that differ from each other. To reach this group, new products and services need to be developed, new messaging needs to be used and varied channels need to be leveraged.



Three recent studies help to shed light on the opportunities and challenges presented by this highly sought after segment.



According to Nielsen, the mass affluent segment consists of more than 13 million households and represents approximately 11 percent of all U.S. households. The segment is defined as having income producing assets between $250,000 and $1M (excluding real estate) and an average household income of $105,000 in 2011. This income is more than 50 percent higher than the national average household income of $62,912. In depth analysis also shows a high correlation between income and assets for targeting purposes.




Well educated, this segment is primarily comprised of baby boomers who grew up in the middle class.  Many are over the age of 55, married and primarily empty nesters, but the segment is far from monolithic since many are in the 45-54 age range with teenagers who have not left the nest yet. The segment as a whole tends to tune out traditional marketing strategies and, interestingly, don't consider themselves to be 'rich'. Instead, they like to be under-the-radar and considered savers or conservative investors. 

Other highlights of the mass affluent consumer (based on the Nielsen research):
  • Their estimated aggregated income producing assets total more than $7.5 trillion
  • Two-thirds are over 55 years old
  • Most are couples without kids or empty nesters
  • They own their own homes
  • They work in Finance, Business and Management careers, or own their own business
  • They are avid readers of newspapers, trade journals, travel and home-related magazines
  • They possess multiple investment accounts including 401K, IRA, CDs and hold a fixed mortgage
  • They are adopters of high-end technology like digital recorders, video game consoles, smartphones and tablet devices
  • They tend to shop less frequently than other groups, but spend more per shopping trip

Product Use

For the financial services industry, while the segment is rich in opportunity, it has actually shrunk over the past few years due to the economic crisis (impact on savings and investments) and because some have moved into the affluent segment. The product use of the mass affluent segment has also decreased in recent years, but is still significantly higher than the mass market. With households in this segment beginning to roll over their 401(k) funds into retirement accounts and many receiving inheritances, the opportunity is still significant. 

Financial Products by Affluence


Banking Channel Use

Channel use for this segment is also different than other segments, with acceptance of direct deposit being high as well as ATM and mobile access. As could be expected, the use of smartphones and tablets increases with income within the mass affluent segment.


Mass affluent households go online multiple times a day, at home and at work, averaging 23 hours a month online. They receive financial and business electronic newsletters and use online sites to track investments, pay bills and even register gift cards. While this segment embraces new technologies, they are still 8 percent less likely than the average consumer to access the internet using their mobile devices.

Obstacles to Deeper Relationships

According to the Nielsen research as well as new research from HNW and a report published by Aite Group and Scivantage, the primary obstacle to a deeper relationship with this segment is the perception of a 'one size fits all' value proposition offered by banks. They feel like they will be treated indifferently despite their balances and relationship potential, and that a bank is not the best option for investment services or financial advice. They also view their relationship with their bank as remote as opposed to being a 'trusted advisor'.

HNV WealthPulse Research, 2012

The segment wants to be recognized for their value and provided services commensurate with their worth. They don't want to be 'sold' products, but provided advice that is client-centric. Waiving bank fees is definitely not enough.

Despite these seemingly negative perceptions, banks still have an opportunity in today's market since the majority of traditional services are still maintained at a bank. In addition, while this segment does not currently use a bank for their investments, the relationships with their non-bank advisors are not as well entrenched as their more affluent counterparts.


HNW, Inc. WealthPulse Research, 2012

Opportunities for Banks

Because this segment also believes they are somewhat ignored by their current investment firms, there is still an opportunity for banks . . . and there are significantly more households in this segment than in the traditional affluent segment. 

“Caught between two worlds—the middle class and wealthy—the mass affluent are looking for solutions and advice, but failing to find it from advisors within the retail banking space,” HNW’s CEO Stacey Haefele said in a statement. “Retail banks have an opportunity to tangibly demonstrate worth by getting customers to consider them for their investment needs.”

Leslie Paladin, senior vice president of HNW, asserts that banks must do a better job of communicating to their mass affluent customers about their services and advisory expertise if they want to compete with wirehouse and independent advisors. She added that banks would do well to push advisors to “work within the ecosystem of the brand.”

Beyond baby boomers, the mass affluent segment also includes a growing sub-segment of Gen-X and Gen-Y consumers that have a potential for banks. While many of these households still have not accumulated enough assets to be considered mass affluent, there are some who do meet the criteria.

“Gen-Xers and Gen-Yers have been far less loyal to their investment providers over the last few years compared to Boomer and Silent Generation investors, indicating that young consumers have yet to find their ideal investment providers,” said Sophie Schmitt, Aite Group Senior Analyst, Wealth Management. “Banks seeking to maximize their ability to retain and grow share of wallet with young investors should work on growing their online investing capabilities and providing more convenient services.”


Reaching the Mass Affluent

HNW, Inc. WealthPulse Research, 2012
The mass affluent is a huge opportunity for banks, but it is not a monolithic customer segment. While the asset and the income range of the mass affluent segment is similar, reaching this segment must go beyond traditional mass media. The group is made up of voracious readers of traditional print (newspapers and magazines), but their taste in reading material reflects their individualized lifestyle. The segment is not best reached through radio. And, while they are significant subscribers to cable packages, they are much less likely to watch TV (broadcast or cable) than the average U.S. household.

Bottom line, financial marketers will need to subsegment the mass affluent based on their demographic and behavioral differences. They will need to understand the channels each subsegment uses, the products they prefer, the media they consume and the way they want to be communicated with. Because of the diversity of this segment, targeted direct communication is the best vehicle. Both digital communication and direct mail should be used, leveraging as much internal and external data available. 

The marketplace is opportune for banks to develop models to serve the mass affluent. But those firms interested will need to move quickly since competition for relationships is high and unique product and service offerings are being developed. Failure to develop a cohesive strategy will not only limit the potential for growth, but could ultimately result in the loss of relationships already in place with this segment.

Additional Insight: