Showing posts with label digital channels. Show all posts
Showing posts with label digital channels. Show all posts

Monday, November 25, 2013

My Digital Banking Nirvana

Last week, I was fortunate enough to be one of the keynote speakers at the inaugural Next Bank Sydney. In preparation for my presentation entitled, 'My Digital Banking Nirvana', I looked globally for mobile banking applications that were the best at being simple, encouraging engagement and being contextual.


With help from the team at Mapa Research, I came up with almost 30 components for my perfect mobile banking relationship from every region of the world. Some were completely unique, while others were mobile applications that multiple financial institutions provide.


Link to my Next Bank Sydney presentation, My Digital Banking Nirvana on SlideShare here


What Makes a Great Mobile Banking Application


In many ways, there is no difference between what makes a great mobile banking application and what makes a great non-banking mobile application. The key components are:
        • Simplicity: Does the app replace a non-mobile process I do often? Does it make my daily life easier? Is it easy to use? In the non-banking world, I love the KeyRing application because it stores multiple loyalty cards in one place on my mobile phone, eliminating the need to carry plastic cards. The app also links to digital offers I can redeem without cutting coupons.
        • Engagement: Does the application stimulate positive interaction, and build a better application from this engagement? For me, my Marriott mobile application does a great job. Beyond providing the standard ability to make reservations and check my loyalty balances, it also allows me to check in early, receive notifications when my room is ready and informs me about special offers through multiple channels.
        • Contextual: One of the benefits of a mobile application vs. an online tool is the ability to provide value based on where I am located. My favorite app from a contextual perspective is OpenTable. Using locational functionality, OpenTable provides suggestions of restaurants based on my current location and previous dining experiences. Reward points are provided for using the app and starting next year, the app will also allow me to pay for my meal using my phone and the OpenTable application.
So, which mobile banking applications meet one or more of the above criteria and could become part of my digital banking nirvana? As could be expected, this list is fluid, since new innovations are being introduced every week, replacing previous applications that were once best-in-class.

Mobile Banking 'Basics'


As an active mobile banking user, there is some functionality that must be the foundation for my best-in-class mobile banking relationship. First of all, as covered in a recent blog post entitled, Banking Innovation for the Fat-Fingered, leveraging mobile imaging technology and my phone's photo capability simplifies mobile banking by removing keystrokes and improving accuracy. Therefore, I expect my future mobile bank to provide the following:
Subscribe to Bank Marketing Strategies

In addition to leveraging the photo capabilities of my phone to simplify my banking, I would prefer to eliminate many of my password and authentication steps, while not having to worry about security issues. One potential solution is to integrate Capital One's new SureSwipe login feature into my new mobile banking relationship. With SureSwipe, I remember a pattern as opposed to passwords, making my login easier as shown in this humorous video.


I also do not want to go through a series of authentication steps just to see the balance in my account. In the U.S., GoBank provides me the opportunity to see my balances with a simple swipe of the finger. GoBank is still one of the few banks in the U.S. to provide this instant balance feature, even though Mapa Research found close to 20% of major banks worldwide offing this functionality.

Banks overseas offering a similar capability included Commonwealth Bank's Kaching, Swedbank's 'balance shake' and Bank of New Zealand's mobile app that allows you to see your entire relationship without a full login.
Other benefits of GoBank I would like to include as part of my digital banking nirvana include having a wide range of customized alerts, a negotiable monthly fee, and their 'fortune teller' that informs me when I might be spending money I will need later. (I covered the reasons I like GoBank in a Financial Brand blog post here)

Going a step further, I would prefer not to type any information at all into my phone for basic mobile banking. If I had USAA's Virtual Assistant powered by Nuance, that would be possible since members are able to use voice commands to perform basic banking tasks. Nuance is also testing a similar solution at U.S. Bank.
  

Mobile Payment Applications


Beyond the basics, no other functionality of mobile banking is as important as payments. Despite high industry attractiveness and relatively low consumer acceptance (in the US at least), mobile payments is the Holy Grail of mobile banking and is the potential tipping point in the battle between bank and non-bank providers. From making payments to tracking payments, the diversity of payment applications globally is exciting.

One of the most comprehensive mobile payment applications is from Commonwealth Bank in Australia. The CommBank Kaching application provides the ability to make P2P payments by bumping phones with another person, using a mobile phone number or email address, or even through Facebook. For bill or merchant payments, QR codes can be used and NFC payments are supported with internal Android functionality and with a CommBank Paytag on iOS devices.
CommBank Kaching Mobile Payments Functionality
Once payments are made, some of the best mobile receipt capabilities I have seen have come from the new banking competition in the U.S. I am a user and a fan of the Moven digital receipt capability that provides me real-time feedback on my PayPass or debit card purchases as well as contextual transaction insights (the application also has spend tracking to compare spending to previous periods and the ability to pay friends by email, mobile or via Facebook).


It would also be nice to include the ability to add pictures to my receipts as offered by Simple in addition to having real-time adjustments to my safe-to-spend and budgeting insight. Simple also provides a very comprehensive search capability that can assist the tracking of spending using 'Google-like' queries or hashtags for spending categorization. Poland's mBank also provides transaction search capability using Google-like queries supported by the excellent Meniga PFM platform.
Simple Real-Time Receipts with Safe-to-Spend 

 Simplified Budgeting


I understand that my mobile phone is not the best platform for enhanced budgeting, but I still want to be able to track how I am doing each month using my mobile device as an adjunct to the online banking capability on my desktop. This requires striking a very careful balance between form and functionality.

As I mentioned, I am a fan of both Moven and Simple for their tracking and budgeting capabilities. Both allow me to see my financial position compared to previous periods and utilize a mobile-first design. The visualization of spending behavior is excellent with the use of easy to understand graphs on both the online and mobile platforms.

For me, one of the best personal financial management (PFM) tools has been developed by MoneyDesktop. Using some of the most advanced user interface design capabilities in the industry, their MoneyMobile solution takes some of the best functionality from their online application and creates an excellent visual interface for mobile devices.
MoneyDesktop Mobile PFM Solution

Channel Integration


As much as I am looking for the ultimate mobile banking experience, I realize that mobile may not be the best channel for all of my interactions with my bank. In those instances when I want to use online banking tools, talk to a customer service representative or visit a branch, I still use the same criteria of simplicity, positive engagement and contextual functionality.

As I travel between online, mobile and my tablet, I don't want to relearn how to conduct my banking. While I may want added functionality that takes advantage of the tactile and interactive benefits of the tablet or the expanded canvas of the desktop computer, I want the 'feel' of the experience to be similar.

Westpac New Zealand recently introduced an excellent device agnostic solution  that provides a similar look and feel across devices. In addition to using a responsive design (making the look conform to the device and how the device is held), the use of a 'central platform' will simplify changes in the future.
WestPac Device Agnostic Central Platform
When I have a problem with my account, the last thing I want to do is search for the appropriate phone number for customer service or wait until I get home. Therefore, the ability to have an integrated customer service capability within my mobile banking application is a must.

NatWest and RBS were the first two banks in the U.K. to offer in-app, real-time customer service whereby a customer can initiate a conversation with a dedicated Mobile Chat advisor. In addition, ING has a mobile application that allows for direct appointment setting with a specific agent in a few easy steps.
NatWest Mobile Chat
Going one step further, Turkey-based Akbank became the first bank to offer video chat. Customers can make a one-click video call from within the bank's online banking site to one of the bank's video enabled service agents. No additional software is needed and the application will soon work on Android and iOS devices as well.
Akbank Video Chat
Finally, for those potential instances I may want to use a branch, the traditional branch just doesn't meet my needs. I want to be in and out as quickly as possible and most likely won't need to see a teller. Banks globally are trying to address this change in customer behavior by scaling back traditional transaction-centric branches and replacing them with either advisory-centric units or technology-enabled branches that leverage video and advanced transaction capabilities.

National Australia Bank (NAB) recently opened their first 'Smart Store' where traditional tellers have been replaced by full service machines. These new branches take less space, will potentially have longer hours and are geared to the lifestyles and digital-savvy nature of Customer 3.0. (This new branch format was covered by The Financial Brand here)


Expanded Mobile Functionality


As with any avid mobile banking user, I want even more from my mobile banking experience than just basic transactions, payments and basic money management. For instance, I have definitely come to enjoy my PNC Bank ATM/Branch Finder, that uses augmented reality to allow my phone to search and find facilities through the screen on my phone. Interestingly, while I find the app useful, I am intrigued as to why the app isn't integrated into my normal mobile banking application (PNC Finder is a separate app).

With the demise of most points programs associated with debit card usage, more elaborate (and potentially more lucrative) merchant-funded rewards programs have taken their place. Unfortunately, the vast majority of these programs require a proactive opt-in on an offer level basis and are connected with the online banking relationship as opposed to mobile banking. This makes taking advantage of any rewards cumbersome at best and downright maddening most of the time.

To address this problem and to provide locational rewards using my phone's GPS capability, Cardlytics is enhancing their merchant-funded reward program in early 2014 to include a much more user-friendly rewards program that will provide offers based on where the customer is located. This functionality is already available from American Express with their My Offers program that leverages both transaction history (what I do) with locational information (where I am).

Support of Wearable Technology


As long as I am trying to develop my digital banking nirvana, I might as well look a bit further into the future and make sure my mobile banking relationship can be supported by wearable technology. While definitely not for budgeting or more difficult mobile banking transactions, both Google Glass and SmartWatches can potentially be effective for mobile alerts, balances, simple transfers/payments and augmented reality ATM/Branch finding capabilities.

Two banks are setting the pace globally for wearable technology integration. Banco Sabadell has already used an open app development forum to create mobile banking using Google Glass. As covered by The Financial Brand, the first iteration of 'banking by glass' includes balance inquiry, the ability to get alerts and find branches and eventually deposit a check by looking at it.

In addition, Westpac New Zealand has created the first SmartWatch banking app that leverages the bank's Cash Tank application. Initially only providing balances without formal login, the application is expected to also include the ability to get alerts and do transfers in the future.

One Last Word on Mobile Banking Innovation from Australia


It is clear that the development of innovative mobile banking applications is an ongoing process with new applications and capabilities being introduced almost every day. Therefore, it is important for those searching for digital banking nirvana to not only keep up with industry trends globally (much of the innovation is being done in the Asia Pacific region as mentioned in my recent blog post on innovation), but to also partner with those banks that have innovation ingrained in their culture.

I was lucky enough to be surrounded by many banks at Next Bank Sydney that obviously do more than just talk the talk on innovation . . . they walk the walk. It was apparent that each institution put a high premium on future thought and were encouraged to think out of the box and not be afraid to fail. The energy level of people from these banks was high and there was an amazing willingness to share from each other as well as leaders globally.

Beyond Australia, banks like CaixaBank and HanaBank, as well as USAA, Moven and Simple in the U.S. are ones to follow. I also am intrigued by BBVA, where their Innovation Center is both robust and very public. In addition to a public Innovation Center web site, there is also a LinkedIn and SlideShare page, sharing ideas that have been developed and discussing the innovation process at BBVA.

It is clear that my digital banking nirvana will be a moving aspirational target. But, if I was to combine what is available globally today into a single mobile banking app, I would have a killer mobile banking relationship with my bank.


Additional Resources


My Digital Banking Nirvana - Jim Marous on SlideShare (Nov. 2013)

Mobile Banking 2013: Are You Following or Leading - Mapa Research (June 2013)

Banks Accelerate Mobile Banking Innovation - Bank Marketing Strategy (June 2013)

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Traditional Banks At Risk Due to Digital Disruption

According to two recent reports from Accenture, 35 percent of banks' market share in North America could be in play by 2020 as traditional branch banking gives way to new digital players. The research also indicates that 15 to 25 percent of today's roughly 7,000 North American financial institutions could be gone as a result of consolidation before 2020.


To combat this shift, Accenture recommends that traditional providers take a radically new approach to distribution, combining a simpler yet more comprehensive branch offering with integrated digital services.


"Digital technology and rapid changes in customer preferences are threatening full-service banks that do business primarily through branches," said Wayne Busch, managing director of Accenture's North America banking practice and author of the report, A Critical Balancing Act: Retail Banking in the Digital Era. "Given the scale of these disruptions, traditional full-service banks, as a group, could lose significant market share by 2020 -- to banks that reorient around digital technologies and to new entrants from the retail and technology sectors."

Digital Disruption


New digital technologies, emerging digital competitors and the extremely rapid changes in customer preferences are threatening to dramatically impact those full-service banks that limit themselves to products and services that get distributed primarily through physical branch channels. The outside disruptors tend to be more agile and more innovative, while traditional banks are weighed down by unprofitable branches, legacy back offices and inefficient silos. 

Business as usual is no longer an option in an industry that could see up to 25 percent of U.S. banks disappear completely.

In conducting online interviews with more than 2,000 US retail banking customers of the 15 leading retail banks in the U.S., Accenture found that 71 percent said they were “satisfied” with their bank and 68 percent said they would be “extremely likely” to recommend their primary bank to a friend, family member or colleague. In addition, only 9 percent of those surveyed switched institutions over the past year.

This loyalty is fragile, however, since more than a quarter (26 percent) of bank customers who remain with their primary provider do so simply because they consider switching to be a hassle, while about half said they haven't seen a competing offer that was attractive enough to make them move. The survey also found that two-thirds of bank customers would consider a branch closure as inconvenient and nearly half would switch banks as a result.

Source: 2013 Accenture Retail Banking Survey

This not only exposes the tenuous relationship banks have with their customers. It also confirms that the right offering and approach can induce them to switch. "The core challenge for banks: how to build a seamless digital customer experience -- and optimize its power with a better and more cost-effective complimentary offering in the branches that customers find so attractive," concludes Accenture.

The Disruption Has Already Begun


According to Accenture, many banks have already begun losing their customers to digital disruptors. The survey showed that customers acquired 34 percent of traditional banking services such as CDs, money market accounts, personal and auto loans and even new checking and savings accounts from institutions other than their primary bank.


Source: 2013 Accenture Retail Banking Survey

While traditional players have the innate advantage of extensive branch networks that the customer still says they value (nearly 60 percent of new product sales are still closed in branches), these same players should be concerned about the the transition to an online sales environment.

The growth rates in online sales since 2012 are strong in several categories, with online auto loans growing from 11 percent to 21 percent in the past year, online sales of mortgages rising from 15 percent last year to 25 percent in 2013 and sales of personal loans through the online channels jumping from 8 percent to 24 percent in only one year.

Source: 2013 Accenture Retail Banking Survey

It is clear that the most fundamental question in the post-financial crisis environment has changed from "how do I find my future customer' to 'how do my future customers find me?" As discussed in my recent post, Is Your Bank Ready for Customer 3.0, digital shifts inside and outside the industry are rapidly changing the information flows and the way that financial firms and customers interact. It is imperative for banks to become an integral part of customers' lives with a ubiquitous presence wherever customers are.

The branch banking conundrum continues, however, since customers still use branches due to proximity. Branches continue to be the number one reason for loyalty and 78 percent believe they will use their branch as often or more often in five years' time. Conversely, with increased use of services like mobile deposit, there has been a 50 percent increase in the number of customers indicating they are using mobile banking in 2013 (32%) than in 2012 (21%).

Source: 2013 Accenture Retail Banking Survey

"The internet is now the most frequently accessed distribution channel on a monthly basis . . . well above the branch. And mobile use has soared in the past year, almost overtaking the ATM in its perceived importance to customers," says the survey.

While the migration to online and mobile channels has been somewhat additive as opposed to a complete transition of behavior, online and mobile banking will continue to weaken the branch's stronghold on the consumer as better applications and more seamless experiences are developed. This migration is imperative due to the high cost to build and maintain a branch and the misalignment between the cost and value of the branch channel.

Subscribe to Bank Marketing Strategies

A Path for the Future


In light of the digital disruption in the marketplace, and as expanded regulation, more onerous capital requirements, economic volatility and consolidation continues, banks need a lower cost operating model that can generate more predictable and sustainable revenues. Branch networks need to be restructured, reducing the number of large footprint offices and increasing the number of 'light' branches and kiosks.

And while some industry observers believe we are quickly moving to a 'branchless' industry, Accenture and others (myself included) believe the environment will be more of a 'less-branch' scenario, at least in the next five to ten years (Chase continues to add branch locations as do other large and mid-sized organizations). But there must be a response to the customer-centric capabilities of the digital players who can leverage big data and analytics to build a better customer experience.

Move to Digital

With inertia being the main reason current bank customers don't switch, traditional banks need to quickly mimic the new digital banking leaders. Agility and a stronger innovative culture will be required to compete effectively as our industry invests to upgrade our legacy back offices and deeper customer insights will need to be leveraged to provide real-time solutions to customer needs. 

As mentioned in my recent post, Bank Product Proliferation: Too Much of a Good Thing, banks and credit unions will also need to eliminate antiquated products, streamline offerings and build new services that leverage the new digital delivery capabilities. By using digital capabilities to track transactional and channel behavior, banks will be able to develop better services and offer new solutions in real-time. This enhances cross-sell opportunities and can increase share of wallet.

Restructure the Branch Network

According to the Accenture research, the top 25 U.S. banks spend more than $50 billion per year to maintain oversized and poorly placed branch networks. While Accenture acknowledges the importance of a branch network, they propose a less costly branch banking model that can balance the sales capability with the digital opportunity:
        • 'Light' branches: Oriented primarily to sales, these offices represent less than a third of the network and are highly automated with a minimal staff and reduced real estate footprint leveraging remote advisory specialists.
        • Kiosks: Representing up to half the total network, these units include feature heavy ATMs with video, and can handle routine transaction activities.
        • Full-service 'hubs': Similar to conventional branches (but fewer in number), these offices offer full sales and transactional support with extended hours and specialized advisors for services like mortgages, investments, business banking, etc.
        • Flagships: A minimal number of strategically located flagships will serve as the center of service-excellence, combining a full range of capabilities including expanded self-service tools.
While many banks are already experimenting with more open and flexible branch formats, there doesn't seem to be a silver bullet yet in response to the digital disruption occurring. A bigger question may be which branches to close or reconfigure, especially with the looming eyes of the Community Investment Act (CRA) regulators looking over the industry's shoulder.

"The acceleration in consumer acceptance of digital banking in the past year -- particularly in the areas of mobile banking and online banking product sales -- foreshadows the need for a very different banking landscape in 2020," said Goodson from Accenture. "Branches remain vital to banks, but they need to be reimagined as one one aspect of a radically new approach to consumers. It is an opportunity to recover profitability, reduce costs and to establish a much more sustainable relationship with customers into the future."

The Best of Both Worlds


Given the scope of disruption impacting our industry, organizations need to start their transformation today if they want to be relevant in the year 2020 according to the complimentary Accenture report, Banking 2020: As the Storm Abates, North American Banks Must Chart a New Course to Capture Emerging Opportunities. 

The winning formula may well be to combine the advantages of the traditional bank with the benefits of the digital bank. By reducing the cost structure of branches and optimizing the products and services provided, yesterday's banks can move into the future leveraging a core strategic asset (a reconfigured branch network) complemented by an enhanced digital experience across all channels.

To succeed, traditional banks must become significantly more agile (no more three year planning cycles), embrace an innovative culture (see my post Banking Innovation: Not Made in the U.S.A.), focus on simplification and optimization while delivering an exceptional customer experience . . . in real-time. This is a very lofty ambition for an industry that historically moves at a snail's pace, but there really are no options.

More importantly, traditional full-service banks must shift their operating philosophy from being a product-oriented organization to being a customer-centric organization with the ability to engage with customers anywhere, anytime they want.

The goal is to become a bigger part of our customers' daily lives and to become integrated with other industries in a seamless manner that reduces friction. Unfortunately, organizations such as PayPal, Square, Google and others are already moving quickly down this path, assuming the role of payments facilitators, supplanting a link to merchants and consumers the banking industry once owned.

Tuesday, November 5, 2013

Banking Innovation: Not Made in the U.S.A.


For the third year in a row, I attended the BAI-Finacle Global Banking Innovation Awards ceremony that takes place as part of the BAI Retail Delivery Conference. This year's program, which recognizes innovation excellence in the banking industry, drew more than 200 nominations from institutions based in over 30 countries.


The two overriding impressions I have had each year when the finalists and winners were announced were that 1) despite industry challenges, there are amazing innovations happening in the banking industry that impact the daily customer experience and 2) with the exception of Citibank in 2011 (for their 'Smart Banking Branch), no other U.S. bank has ever won the award.



Traditionally, the financial services industry in the U.S. has been slow to innovate compared to many other industries due to compliance and regulatory obligations, dependence on large internal and external infrastructures and the need to focus on security and privacy. In addition, the lack of a formal structure or process for innovation or dedicated funding also inhibits initiatives.

Despite these limitations, the industry globally continues their effort to innovate, with varying degrees of success. Some institutions are recognized regularly for their efforts, with some regions (Asia Pacific) being hotbeds for new ideas and innovation. In addition, social media banking innovations are being found in places like India, Brazil and Nigeria.

The Efma and Infosys Finacle sponsored study, Innovation in Retail Banking: Simplify Technology to Innovate provides a good perspective on global innovation trends, ways banks can overcome some of the barriers to innovation and why some banks have been so successful in their efforts. This year is the fifth year of the study and it appears that banks worldwide are increasing their investment in innovation and beginning to structure organizations in a way that is more conducive to innovative practices.

While defining innovation continues to be a challenge, examples of new ideas globally illustrate the need for banks to measure not only against domestic competition but also against global standards. The key findings of the study were:
        • More banks have an innovation strategy: 60% had a formal strategy in 2013 vs. 37% in 2009.
        • Investment in innovation is increasing: In 2009, more banks were decreasing innovation investment than increasing. Today, 77% of banks say they are increasing investment vs. 5% decreasing (personally, I am concerned about the definition of innovation investment in this study).

Subscribe to Bank Marketing Strategies
        • Most banks believe they are becoming more innovative: 76% believe they are becoming more innovative vs. 6% who said they were becoming less innovative.

        • Performance metrics are focused on revenue and customers: Measurement of profitability from innovation is less common.

        • IT systems and culture are the biggest barriers to innovation: IT systems were the biggest barrier to innovation for banks of all sizes. Culture and silos are issues with large banks more than smaller organizations. Silo based IT systems have a huge impact on time to market for large banks.

        • Business processes need development: Speed, agility and efficiency is an area in need of development.

        • Additional factors can improve innovation: Other capabilities that would improve innovation include the ability to personalize products, seamless multichannel integration and having a single customer view.


The study also measured the current status of innovation deployment in mobile and online and found that:
        • On average, out of 10 mobile and online innovations measured, deployment averages around two per bank, with larger banks averaging around 3 innovations and smaller banks having only 1 of the 10 innovations deployed on average.
        • Mobile P2P payments have been deployed by 29% of the banks and mobile NFC payments by 23%. Mobile location offers have been deployed by 18% of the banks with an additional 51% planning on deploying.
        • Direct-only banking has been deployed by 23% of the banks, but only an additional 21% have this in their plan.
        • Gamification has only been used by 9% of banks.

Innovation in the U.S.


So why is it that in the USA, where more banks and some of the largest banks in the world exist, is true innovation so difficult to find? Here is what some of the people who watch innovation regularly told me.
"Many U.S. Banks are so invested in their legacy business models that it makes it very hard to undertake truly disruptive innovation projects. Banks in emerging markets have to be innovative to reach their customers, many of whom don't have access to the broad range of choices that Americans have." - JP Nicols, co-founder Bank Innovators Council
"While there are many reasons U.S. banks are innovation laggards, I think legacy technology, regulation, compliance, and risk aversion have to top the list of reasons why we're not seeing more movement." - Bradley Leimer, Vice President, Mechanics Bank
"The US is a major leader in internet innovations but, outside this, it has been behind most other regions of the world on mobile developments. This is largely due to the tariffs and state splits between cellphone usage and providers which, when you get to China or Africa is a totally different position. These newer markets do not have the old systems in place and therefore saw mobile as a leapfrog for digital services to the customer. American banks just don't see it that way, and see it more as an overlay to what's already there." - Chris Skinner, Author of the new book Digital Bank

The Efma/Infosys study found that 73% of banks in the Americas (they did not break out the U.S. specifically) were increasing investment in innovation in 2013 compared to 2012. This is less than for banks in Middle East, Africa and Asia Pacific but is more than Europe. By far the biggest area of increase for the Americas was in 'channels', with the 'product' category being the lowest area of increase.

Interestingly, 86% of banks said they had become more innovative in the last 12 months, though this may be from a lower base than in other regions. Again the 'channels' category was the area of highest increase, with 71% of banks saying they had become more innovative.

The innovation performance self-assessment scores were the lowest in the Americas out of the four regions – just 4.08 on a scale of 1 to 7. Innovation performance in 'channels' was the highest, and innovation performance in 'products' was the lowest (a big difference from Middle East and Africa where innovation in 'products' is the strongest area for banks). Overall, it is clear that the focus in this region is on channels.

 

Barriers to Innovation


In contrast to the other regions, the main barrier to innovation for the Americas, according to the Efma/Infosys study, was culture rather than IT systems, which was only the third largest barrier. Regulation was the second most significant barrier. The least important barriers were senior management and organization silos.

In conversations with my counterparts in the industry, here are the barriers they mentioned.
"Two things. The first is that innovation is simply not in the DNA of most bankers. They've been trained throughout their whole career to identify and avoid risks, and innovation is about taking small risks and failing fast and cheaply and learning from those mistakes to get to the right answer quickly. The second is analysis paralysis. Most banks have too many silos with conflicting agendas, and that makes it hard to actually put new ideas into action. Consequently, those few innovators who do exist in banks find themselves surrounded by the 'business prevention department'." - JP Nicols
"The U.S. market is plagued with many more problems than its international peers - we have a more complicated system of financial players, embedded legacy technology and processes for everything from acquisition to money movement, from telcos to payment providers - and in spite of changing client behavior, we continue to prop up legacy financial services like paper checks." - Bradley Leimer
"Lethargy and lack of competitiveness. Lethargy embraces everything from 'oh, the regulators won't allow it' to 'if ain't broke, don't fix it' to 'but the legacy, the legacy, the legacy'.  If Barack Obama ran a typical bank, he'd ask 'can we fix it?' and the team would answer 'why bother?'" - Chris Skinner 

BAI/Finacle Innovation Winners for 2013


This year's awards were presented to the following organizations in the following categories:
        • Product and Service Innovation: CaixaBank (Spain) and Hana Bank (South Korea)
        • Channel Innovation: Alior Bank (Poland)
        • Innovation in Internal Process Improvement: ZUNO Bank (Slovak Republic)
        • Innovation in Societal and Community Impact: Standard Bank (South Africa)
        • Disruptive Innovation in Banking: Hana Bank (South Korea)
        • Honorable Mention for Disruptive Business Model: Jibun Bank (Japan)
        • Most Innovative Bank: CaixaBank (Spain)
To learn more about the winners and their innovations, go to www.baiglobalinnovations.com.

As can be seen from the winners (and finalists') entries, much of the innovation that was recognized dealt with moving from traditional to digital and mobile channels. In addition, it is important to note the impact of culture as it relates to innovation. Not only did Hana Bank and CaixaBank have multiple entires for this award, but CaixaBank has been named the most innovative bank two out of the last three years.

Congratulations to the winners and I am sure we will soon see more examples of innovation in the U.S., either by traditional financial institutions or by one of the many newer neobanks that have been created or from some of the financial intermediaries that are providing the tools for U.S. banks to serve customers better.

When asked about the dearth of U.S. representation, Debbie Bianucci, president of the BAI stated, "Each year the BAI-Finacle Global Banking Innovation Awards program receives numerous submissions from innovative U.S. banks, and there have been finalists from the U.S. in both 2011 and 2012. Each year we receive over 200 submissions from banks from around the world, all who have inspiring stories to tell about how they serve their customers differently. It’s a very competitive program with just a few finalists and winners. We will  encourage U.S. banks to continue to submit their innovations for the 2014 awards program, which begins in January, 2014."  

Which bank(s) do you believe are the most innovative in the United States? Who has a chance in 2014?

I would love to hear your comments.

Additional Resources



Innovation in Retail Banking: Simplify Technology to Innovate - Efma and Infosys Finacle (Sept. 2013)


Sunday, November 3, 2013

Is Your Bank Ready For Customer 3.0

The banking industry is in the midst of a significant shift in customer behavior fueled by new channels, new competitors and new shopping behaviors. Today's customer is hyper-connected, highly informed and demanding a highly personalized approach with regards to communication, product development and customer service.


These customers cannot be defined by a specific age or income category or geographic parameter, but by their ability (and desire) to adopt and apply new technologies to meet their banking needs.


Say "Hello" to Customer 3.0.


Customer 3.0 begins their bank and credit union product shopping experience at their desk, in their car or on their couch, relying on friends and family reviews and published reviews across social media channels. Instead of walking into a local branch office and sitting down to open an account during banking hours, these customers purchase their banking services much like they purchase music, books or other products . . . online, 24/7.

As Brett King highlighted in his book, Bank 3.0, the new customer doesn't 'go to' their bank or credit union or rely on a physical distribution network. Banks and credit unions need to find and effectively engage customers who are mobile-first and have vast choices and a 'want it now' attitude. This paradigm shift in the balance of power between banks and the customer positions Customer 3.0 as a power player who is firmly in charge of their personal buying process.

To find and engage with Customer 3.0, financial institutions need to transform their back office and delivery networks and begin to think like the new customer. They need to understand that the competition is not just other traditional banks or even the digital-first 'neobanks'. Instead, we are competing across all of the touchpoints used by Customer 3.0, where experiences are shaped by the latest in retail, gaming, search and mobile technologies.

In a just released research report, Say Hello to Customer 3.0, Accenture discusses the transformation of the banking customer over time and the need to move from being a financial facilitator to becoming a part of the ecosystem where Customer 3.0 interacts. The report also discusses the need to move from mass marketing techniques to a highly personalized approach that takes advantage of both structured and unstructured data to improve the overarching customer experience.

Defining Customer 3.0


Unlike the customer of the past, Customer 3.0 is not defined by traditional demographics like age, income, geographics or gender. Instead, they are defined by the way they leverage new technologies to meet their individual needs. Digitally astute, mobile-first and socially connected, Accenture found Customer 3.0 to have some generally common attributes. I provide my take on what these attibutes mean to bank product managers and marketers:
        • Highly Informed: Customer 3.0 leverages the information available on the internet more than any previous generation. They use comparison sites and associated apps to gather insight about the banks and products they want to purchase before a bank even knows they are shopping.

          The change in bank shopping behavior was discussed in my previous post, Digital Shopping Has Transformed the Bank Purchase Funnel, and more generally in the Accenture report, Energizing Global Growth: Understanding the Changing Consumer. Customer 3.0 starts (and sometimes finishes) their bank shopping experience in the digital world.

          My Take: Traditional media is no longer enough for acquiring or cross-selling the new customer. The importance of digital marketing tools, such as retargeting, must become part of ever bank and credit union marketers tool kit.


Subscribe to Bank Marketing Strategies

        • Price Sensitive: Saving money and/or 'getting a deal' is more important to Customer 3.0, who places an emphasis on a fair value exchange as opposed to simply buying on brand name or convenience alone.

          My Take: While Customer 3.0 is price sensitive, they will pay for a product that saves time and/or money in the long run. Banks and credit unions should not view this attribute as a message that 'free is better', but as an opportunity to build services that can be differentiated. This also bodes well for merchant-funded rewards if the offers are targeted and easy to use.
        • Socially Connected: Today's social networks provide a double edged sword for financial institutions. While serving as a platform for sales, social media also is a platform for bad news, poor reviews and complaints to travel faster than ever to more people than ever before.

          My Take: Banks and credit unions need to be highly responsive to customers who use social media to air their grievances. It is usually best to respond publicly using the same channel the customer used to provide public closure.

          From a sales perspective, using social media for 'likes' and 'friending' is not enough. Social media should be leveraged for proactive and measurable sales efforts when possible (see Financial Brand's review of Navy Federal Credit Union's Facebook $200 million selling effort here). Channels like YouTube have also been used successfully to promote, educate and reinforce positive customer experiences.
        • Trust Their Peers: Customer 3.0 is not shy. They are very comfortable receiving and sharing reviews on social networks and within apps wherever possible. Sites like BankRate, My Bank Tracker, Find a Better Bank, in addition to Facebook and Twitter provide the online platform to provide reviews, advice and opinions instantaneously. Recent research reinforces this trend with 14 percent of customers trusting advertisements while 78 percent trust peer recommendations.

          My Take: Monitoring recommendation and review sites should be part of the job of marketing and the customer experience areas of the bank. In addition, much like restaurants and retailers, banks and credit unions should seek positive online reviews from satisfied customers as part of daily social interactions.
        • Self-Promotion: Aligned with the above attribute, Customer 3.0 will publish and promote themselves, their opinions and their decisions through social channels (myself included) while many other customer groups are much more shy about their daily activities.

          My Take: Some banks are proactively monitoring the social network activities of their customers not only to gauge satisfaction and to build a more robust profile but also to determine who may have the strongest 'social clout'. Moven may have the most public social monitoring feature with their CredScore. With a close eye on privacy issues, the ability to determine a customer's social influence can be a powerful marketing tool going forward.
        • Instant Gratification: Influenced by the impact of online books by Kindle, music via iTunes and simple bank account opening by GoBank, Simple, Moven and PNC's Virtual Wallet, Customer 3.0 can be accurately described as the 'now' generation. They want to be able to open accounts, transact business, talk to customer service and view their financial position quickly, easily and in real time.

          My Take: Innovation in the eyes of Customer 2.0 may not be in the form of more features and functions, but simplified capabilities that occur seamlessly. From simple account openings to seeing balances without needing multilayer authentication (GoBank Balance Bar), to instant mobile receipts (Moven), banks and credit unions need to remove complexity from everyday banking, allowing customers to bank where, when and how they want.

          The recent innovations by Mitek Systems using the camera functionality on a phone for mobile deposits, mobile billpay, mobile account opening and most recently, mobile balance transfer exemplifies the importance of instant gratification.
        • Security Unconscious: Despite all of the talk about public discourse around privacy and security, Customer 3.0 does not seem to be nearly as concerned about viruses, spam or phishing attacks, uploading and downloading more digital information than any other group. This comfort extends to their confidence in doing banking transactions online or on a mobile device.

          My Take: For Customer 2.0, the need to emphasize safety and security is less of an issue when wanting them to try new online and/or mobile services. That said, this security could be short lived if a major breach occurs within the banking industry. In addition, the comfort with sharing personal information allows financial marketers greater access to insight that can be used for improved targeting, product development and communication.

Engaging Customer 3.0


To better engage Customer 3.0, Accenture recommends that financial institution become ubiquitous, melding into the digital ecosystem where Customer 3.0 already interacts. This is a 'pull' as opposed to 'push' environment, where banking develops products, services and content the customer seeks as opposed to being sold.

The expectations are not being set by historical banking organizations, processes and products but by other more progressive industries that have already embraced digital real-time transactions, robust 'big data' insight, geolocational capabilities and new ways to communicate through offline, online and social channels. 

The retail industry has set the bar high for developing a single customer view and removing product silos. They also have made the customer aware of the new 1:1 marketing potential and the ability to listen and interact with customers on their terms, providing products and services that add value and enhance daily life.

Below is a great narrative on the expectations of Customer 3.0 and the interrelationship between what they expect from banking compared to what they are already receiving from other companies they like and admire.




To improve engagement with Customer 3.0, there are seven barriers that must be addressed that are inextricably linked to the banking industry's current operating model:

        1. Trust: While progress has been made to build trust within the industry, Customer 3.0 doesn't differ from other customers when it comes to making choices between different banks and credit unions. They turn to friends, family and their extended virtual community. Banks that avoid customer 'surprises' and improve transparency will benefit.

        2. Advice: Progressive Insurance exemplifies the way a financial institution can provide an unbiased perspective with their comparison shopping tool. Likewise, banks can provide tools that are unbiased as well as content that can help educate customers. American Express does this well with their Open Forum and many banks have developed educational blogs around financial planning, etc.

        3. Location: Financial institutions need to find more ways for the digital experience to provide many of the benefits of the physical experience. Customer 3.0 is reluctant to visit branches except for the most complex purposes, so the development of significantly better tablet applications that are tactile and more robust is a great place to start.

        4. Loyalty: Loyalty is harder than ever to secure since most banks are followers as opposed to leaders and have become more of a commodity or utility as opposed to being differentiated. To build stronger loyalty, innovation will become more valued and the ability to provide services beyond traditional banking will be rewarded.

        5. Price: Customer 3.0 is very aware that it is less costly to serve digitally than through a physical location, but is willing to share the benefits of this lower cost delivery. Unfortunately, serving digitally is not always less expensive, so improved customer education and the ability to generate fees from value-added services will be important in the future.

        6. Time: Finding ways to serve Customer 3.0 at a time that suits them is not difficult for many transactions, but finding a way to serve this segment when interaction is needed is not as easy. Live customer support through digital channels will become an important differentiator.

        7. Relevance: The collaboration with non-financial providers to stay relevant will become more important since Customer 3.0 wants their financial provider to be inextricably linked to their everyday lives. Location-based rewards, improved P2P capabilities, etc. are the foundation for this needed relevance.

Attracting and Retaining Customer 3.0


To attract and retain Customer 3.0, banks need to come to the realization that change is needed. They need to embrace the need to innovate and undergo a overhaul of the way they do business as Brett King highlighted in his book, Bank 3.0 and is done by Chris Skinner in his newest book, Digital Bank: Strategies to Succeed as a Digital Bank (interview with Chris Skinner here).

According to Accenture, banks need to engage with Customer 3.0 on their terms by:
          • Redefining their business model
          • Engaging whenever, wherever Customer 3.0 desires
          • Changing the way products are created
          • Utilizing technology to gain greater insight into customer behaviors
          • Delivering innovative experiences
          • Rewarding loyalty
In other words, to defend share of wallet from organizations like PayPal, Walmart, Visa, MasterCard, Google, Apple . . . , banks will need to collaborate with the customer in a way that assists with new product development, service and channel experience. In short, banks need to move from being a financial facilitator to becoming part of the digital ecosystem where the customer interacts.

The question becomes, can traditional banks and credit unions remake themselves for an environment where the customer has all of the power?

Additional Resources


Say Hello to Customer 3.0 - Accenture (2013)