Showing posts with label alerts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label alerts. Show all posts

Thursday, November 14, 2013

The Engagement and Revenue Potential of Mobile Alerts

To drive greater mobile banking adoption and engagement, banks and credit unions need to take a more active role in helping customers proactively manage their finances through real-time notification of events that impact their accounts.


Beyond simple balance and transaction updates, alerts can provide the foundation for greater interaction with your customers, increasing engagement, lowering servicing costs and even providing potential revenue opportunities.


As discussed in my post, Is Your Bank Ready for Customer 3.0, today's mobile-savvy customer expects their bank to provide instantaneous feedback as to their financial position and to move from being a financial facilitator to being part of their everyday, always-on digital ecosystem. A new white paper from Fiserv entitled, Enterprise Alerts: The Superhighway to Delighting Customers With Timely, Relevant and Actionable Information discusses how financial institutions can develop a comprehensive alert strategy that can take advantage of this opportunity while also meeting regulatory requirements related to customer notifications.

Despite the benefits of alerts to financial institutions, adoption of alerts (similar to online banking and bill pay) have flatlined according to Javelin Strategy and Research. In a recent study entitled, Road Map to Alerts 3.0: A New Channel Emerges for Interactive Finance, Javelin predicts that the number of consumers who receive email or text alerts is only 34% currently, and will only grow by 4% annually through 2016 unless the industry deepens the pool of users by upgrading alert technology, providing more real-time insight and making alerts more useful and relevant.


Source: Javelin Strategy & Research (2012)
As could be expected, the banks with the most successful alert strategies (based on households receiving alerts) are the larger banks, while community bank and credit union customers/members are the least likely to have received an alert according to Javelin research. While Bank of America customers are the most likely to have received an email alert, Chase customers were the most likely to receive a text alert in the past 30 days.



Bank of America Mobile and Online Banking Alert Selection Pages


Alert Channel Preference


At a time when the vast majority of interaction with online and mobile banking involves simplistic balance inquiries or funds transfer, expanding the number and variety of alerts can lead to a significantly higher level of engagement that can deepen the relationship with the customer.

According to the Javelin research, while email continues to be the primary delivery channel for alerts, text alerts are the fastest growing type of alert even though this form is usually used to supplement the email variety. As mobile banking downloadable app usage continues to grow (currently at about 50% of mobile banking users), opt-out push notification alerts continue to grow.

In early 2013, Varolii Corporation did research on mobile banking preferences entitled, Can You Bank On Your Banking App, which found that consumers differ significantly in the way they want to be contacted regarding their account. Some of these preferences may be correlated with the way in which they are currently being notified by their financial institution.

Source: Can You Bank on Your Banking App?, Varolii Corporation (Jan. 2013) 

With such a wide variety of preferences, banks and credit unions must find a way to economically tie their alert system to a unified system of engagement that does not confuse the customer with too many notifications but still allow the customer a degree of customization. The key is to ensure that time-critical information is delivered to the customer in a manner that both informs and allows for immediate action.

"An enterprise alert strategy should include a wide variety of alerts distributed via multiple end points and devices," says Jim Tobin, senior vice president and general manager, Mobile Solutions from Fiserv. "This will enable financial institutions to serve customers at different stages in their lives while keeping pace with regulatory demands."

Subscribe to Bank Marketing Strategies

Types of Alerts


While the origin of alerts were to notify customers of overdrafts or potential fraud potential, the variety of alerts within downloadable applications has expanded significantly over the past 18 months resulting in an increase in engagement and a better potential customer experience. In the past, the majority of alerts have involved a one-directional flow of information from the bank to the customer. Examples include:

        • Balance alerts: these could include overdraft or NSF alerts
        • Scheduled alerts: could be balance or other insight delivered on a scheduled basis
        • Event-based alerts: Could be based on a bill payment or potential fraudulent activity
While the majority of the above were usually done via email, the movement to using SMS channels opened the door for potential conversations between the bank and the customer. This expanded to 'push' notifications that allowed customers to instantly take action on an alert.

Push notifications enable customers to not only view an alert, but initiate a transaction in response to an alert within a secure app . . . in real time. For example, instead of simply getting notified that there is a low balance on an account, the alert can include a response option that allows for a transfer to be made using the mobile device. This deepens the engagement level, provides the customer more control and ultimately increases customer satisfaction.

As the use of smartphones continues to grow, push notifications are the expected level of engagement for 'Customer 3.0'.

"With push notification, financial institutions have an opportunity to transform their existing alerts offering from a reactive, event-driven service to a proactive personal financial management (PFM) tool," says Fiserv's Tobin.

According to Fiserv, Push notification uniquely provide the ability for financial institutions to evaluate and measure alert programs. Unlike text and SMS, push notifications within the mobile banking app are not limited by carrier policy restrictions. For this reason, push notifications open the door for innovation and facilitate Enterprise Process Management (EPM) with the ability to measure the value of alerts.

Bottom line, an expanded alert strategy with the resultant engagement by customers can transform a one-way, static alert offering into a proactive personal financial management tool.

Not surprisingly, the new digital banks (Moven, GoBank and Simple) as well as several banks overseas have leveraged the power of mobile push alerts the most effectively. The options available and the ability to personalize the alert 'experience' can be seen below.



Monetizing Alerts


I have covered the potential for financial institutions to charge a fee for services that provide 'added value' to banking and credit union customers. While most banks have been reluctant to charge a fee for almost anything since the Occupy movement, some institutions (most notably U.S. Bank and Regions Bank) have built a strategy around charging fees for 'premium' services. (see my post on monetizing mobile and building a fee-based strategy here and here).

In a report from Market Rates Insight entitled, Growth and Revenue Potential of Emerging Financial Services, evidence is provided that banks and credit unions are missing an opportunity to charge for services that go beyond basic. While not covering push notifications per se, this 168-page study covers 13 different emerging financial services, with insights into fee optimization, targeting, institutional differences and bundling options.

One of the services they do cover is the ability to charge for identity theft notifications which could be one of the many push notifications offered by a financial institution. According to the research, 82% of the households surveyed said they were likely to use identity theft alerts, with an average acceptable monthly fee of $4.07. The level of acceptance and perceived value of the service was not impacted significantly by either type of institution or type of customer (while women did value the alert slightly more than men).

According to Dr. Dan Geller from Market Rates Insight, “Staying informed through alerts is highly desired and valued by consumers. Nearly nine of ten banking customers want identity theft alerts, and nearly eight of ten banking customers desire low balance alerts.”

While I realize the value of an identity theft alert is definitely more than a basic alert, I believe there are alerts that the customer could receive that could be charged for as part of a bundle. For instance, the ability to charge a small monthly fee (let's say $2.00) for the following expanded set of alerts could be tested:
        • Credit card or checking account low threshold alert
        • Upcoming bill (within 2 days) where available funds are not sufficient
        • Large recurring bill notification (15 day notice) for mortgage, rent, car payment, tax bill, etc.
        • Customized personal notification (owe a friend, non-financial promise made)
        • Integrated personal calendar

Developing an Enterprise Alert Strategy


According to Fiserv, an enterprise alert strategy should include two way information flow and should be seamlessly integrated with all banking channels to support information access and management reporting. It should be both easy to enroll for and easy for the customer to make changes to preferences or to opt-out.

Since the potential for a broad-based alert strategy can be difficult to implement, Fiserv recommends a phased approach with different stages to implementation including:


        • Step 1: Account-centered alerts that are specific to account activity (low balance, direct deposit, large debits)
        • Step 2: Event-based alerts that indicate when an event may prompt a follow-up action (bill payment due, P2P request)
        • Step 3: Security-related alerts that notify the customer when accounts may be compromised (international charges, password change)
        • Step 4: Customer care information that can be initiated by the customer or the financial institution (CD maturing, lease up for renewal)
        • Step 5: Actionable insights that provide financial management tips and guidance based on the customer's activity (changes in financial activity compared to historical data)

While it may be difficult for some banks or credit unions to reach the final stage of implementation, digitally savvy and mobile-first 'Customer 3.0' expects this level of partnership from their financial institution. While providing such an array of alerts may seem like we could bombard the customer with communication, today's alert strategy keeps the customer in control of what they want to see and what they don't find important. The key element is providing choice.

Marketing of Alerts


As I have said in previous posts, "If you build it, they won't come." In other words, just because you have a robust, interactive alert capability doesn't mean that customers will take advantage of this opportunity (assuming they can find the option on their online and/or mobile banking site.

Banks and credit unions should focus early efforts on those customers most likely to want and use alerts actively (low hanging fruit). These would most likely be those customers who already are using online and/or mobile banking actively and would best understand the benefits of customizable alerts. 

Messaging within the online and mobile banking platforms is the least expensive and most effective way to begin. Fiserv suggests segmenting the target audience by digital personas to determine which alert(s) would be most valuable for each segment.

Beyond messaging within the online and mobile banking sites, other effective ways to communicate the benefits and use of alerts include:
        • Frontline staff: leveraging the referral power of customer-facing personnel
        • Email: a series of email communication regarding alerts with direct links to preference pages on the customer's online banking site (Don't forget the power of engaging offline customers as well)
        • Ad campaign: Because of the innovative nature of robust alerts, ad campaigns have been used as a way to acquire new mobile-first customers
        • Branch and ATM signage: While branch traffic is less than in the past, branch and ATM signage is still effective at raising the awareness of customers who may or may not use online or mobile banking
        • ATM receipts: One of my perennial favorites is the use of QR codes on ATM receipts to encourage both the sign-up for mobile banking but the selection of alert preferences. Linking to the alert marketing page of a bank, these receipts are an inexpensive way to reach mobile customers and prospects.

Banks and credit unions have a unique opportunity to expand the functionality and engagement of both online and mobile banking by developing an enterprise approach to alerts that satisfies customer needs, addresses regulatory issues and can generate revenue. Since the implementation of a robust alert strategy is still in formative stages, financial institutions have a unique opportunity to develop both a standard (free) set of alerts along with premium (fee-based) alerts that customers value and are willing to pay for.

This is a great time for banks to step up to the plate to provide a service customers will value and to generate needed fees at the same time. The question is . . . will we give another innovative set of services away for free?

Additional Resources


Monday, July 29, 2013

The Revenue Power of Emerging Financial Services

With interest rates remaining low and traditional fee income impacted by recent government regulations, banks and credit unions are increasingly looking for new ways to make up the shortfall in revenues.


Despite continued pressure from consumers around 'fee anxiety' and our industry's habit of giving most services away for free, there are still opportunities to promote customer loyalty and generate new non-interest sources of income according to new research.


In the most comprehensive fee optimization study of its kind from Market Rates Insight, Inc. entitled, 'Growth and Revenue Potential of Emerging Financial Services', the importance and value of new financial services are evaluated to determine new revenue sources as well as ways to attract and retain customers. In the study, it was found that there is a willingness from consumers to accept 'value-added fees' for services that are viewed as valuable.

"For the foreseeable future, deposit rates will remain flat and loan demand will be soft, so financial institutions will need to rely on fee revenues for income growth," states Dan Geller, EVP of research at Market Rates Insight. "To convert services from 'free' to 'fee', banks and credit unions will have to identify new services that consumers want and are willing to pay for. The study shows organizations how to use service fees to expand profits and penetration with both new and existing customers."

The 150-page study (available here) examines 13 emerging financial services and includes a competitive survey of 10 financial institutions, assessing the importance and value of each service, segmenting banks and credit unions as well as demographic segments for variances. The highlights of the study include:

      • Financial institutions can sell four times the number of financial services they currently do by offering more 'leading edge' services consumers find valuable
      • Only 13.1 percent of consumers receive emerging financial services from their financial institution, yet 54.6 percent of consumers who don't have these services find them important
      • The highest potential from growth in revenue from emerging services is with larger organizations
      • The highest ranking services in terms of potential growth are credit score reporting (71.4%), identity theft alerts (70.8%), payment protection services (64.6%) and same-day bill pay (58.7%).
      • The value placed on emerging financial services is inversely correlated to the age segment of consumers, with younger consumers placing higher values on the new services evaluated
      • Consumers value and will pay a premium for specific bundles of services more than they value individual services, but there is a point of diminishing return for the revenue potential of bundles relative to the expense of additional services
      • The mid-range revenue potential for an optimal bundle of emerging services is $10.12 per month.

Growth Potential


The study found that financial institutions are underutilizing the potential for selling emerging financial services to consumers regardless of the institution size or type or consumer demographic segment. Overall, only 13.1 percent of consumers were found to use any of the emerging services reviewed, while 54.6 percent of the consumers surveyed indicated that they would be willing to pay a monthly fee for the service(s). 

While there is significant potential for growth with all sized organizations, the potential was correlated to the size of organization, with larger institutions having a greater opportunity than regional banks, credit unions or smaller financial institutions.

As can be seen from the chart below, there is significant variability between the current use and potential demand for emerging financial services. As could be expected, the use of overdraft protection was currently the highest (42.9%), followed by low balance alerts (23.3%). Interestingly, identity theft protection was the most popular emerging financial service, with 91.9 percent of households desiring this service overall, followed by overdraft services (86.3%) and low balance alerts (80%).


Services with the greatest growth potential in the future include credit score reporting (71.4%), identity theft alerts (70.8%), payment protection services (64.6%) and same-day bill payment (58.7%). In fact, virtually all of the services analyzed had significant upside potential.

"These findings are significant because they come at a time when banks and credit unions are experiencing a decline in fees on traditional services such as NSF and interchange fees due to new regulations and greater scrutiny by the CFPB," states Geller.

Importance and Value of Emerging Financial Services


The level of importance consumers place on various services has a strong and positive correlation to the perceived value of the services. Based on the findings in the report, the services desired supported three major functions in our evolving lifestyle:
      1. Concern for digital identity and security: reflected by identity theft alerts and credit score reporting services
      2. Increased mobility: reflected by mobile deposit and bill pay services
      3. Desire for Efficiency: reflected by the desire for same-day bill pay, person-to-person payments, payment protection and overdraft services 
By evaluating the level of desire for these services and testing different pricing points, banks and credit unions can develop an escalation model of service features. In other words, higher fees can be charged for a premium level of service (same day mobile deposit) with a lower fee charged for a slower level of service.

In the report from Market Rates Insight, each of the 13 emerging financial services were evaluated with regards to level of importance from consumers not already owning the service, with a dollar value placed on each level of importance. An average level of importance and average value was also assigned. Digging even deeper, the report also analyzed each of the 13 services with regard to type/size of institution.

Mobile Deposits

As an example, 46 percent of the consumers who do not currently use mobile deposit services find this service important to some degree, ranging from slightly important (17.5%) to extremely important (3.5%). Based on the study, the average value consumers place on this service is $2.63, with the value jumping to $5.60 for the consumers who find mobile deposit extremely important. The potential is higher for larger institutions, with customers of smaller organizations willing to pay a bit less. 

Mobile Deposit Distribution of Importance (all institutions)

Mobile Deposit Distribution of Value (all institutions)


This analysis is consistent with a separate mobile banking study conducted by ath Power Consulting where it was found that one in three consumers would be willing to pay for some mobile banking services. Remote deposit capture was the most sought after mobile banking feature according to the study.

"Retail customers are becoming less resistant to monthly fees for mobile, with a third saying they would be willing to pay for mobile banking," said Michael McEvoy, ath managing director. That is up from the one in five during last year's study, he said. 


Despite this demand and value placed on the service, banks and credit unions remain reluctant to charge for mobile deposits. While a few banks and credit unions are testing the waters like U.S. Bank and Regions Bank, all are charging substantially less than the price customers are willing to pay according to the research.

Beyond the revenue potential for remote deposit capture, institutions can save operating overhead as well. According to a new report from Javelin Strategy and Research, financial institutions can save $50 for every customer encouraged to use mobile deposits. Javelin estimates that it costs about $4.25 for each deposit made in person in a branch. The same transaction costs $0.10 when done using a remote deposit capture application.

Identity Theft Alerts

Another example of significant revenue potential is with identity theft alerts. Consistent with many recent mobile banking findings around concern for security and desire for more mobile alerts, the potential for generating additional fee income with identity theft alerts (as well as low balance alerts) should not be ignored.

As shown below, 40.8 percent of customers find the offering of identity theft alerts either 'very important' or 'extremely important'. Not only is the distribution of importance skewed positive, but so is the value placed on this emerging service. While those who do not find the service as attractive are willing to pay more for the service, the average monthly value placed on the service is still $2.71.


Identity Theft Alerts Distribution of Importance (all institutions)

IdentityTheft Alert Distribution of Value (all institutions)

In the MRI report, all 13 emerging services are analyzed the same as above for all institution sizes as well as for each financial institution type, providing a way for bank marketers and product managers to compare results for like institutions.


Demographic Perspectives on Emerging Financial Services


The overall average importance of each of the 13 emerging financial services analyzed is relatively similar when viewed based on gender. There are some differences, however, with females finding mobile deposit capture more important than males (72.8% vs. 65%) and male consumers finding prepaid loadable cards more important.

While the differences in importance of emerging financial services is close to identical from a gender perspective, there is a substantial difference in the value that each gender places on these services. In fact, males placed an average value ($4.16) that was close to twice that of their female counterparts ($2.44). 

From a demographic perspective, the MRI study found that the more mature the consumer, the lower the value placed on most emerging financial services. Possibly reflecting the need for more guidance in financial affairs, the younger demographic segments placed a very high value on security, credit reporting and identity theft services, while the Gen Y and Gen X consumer also placed a high value on eldercare services, possibly reflecting the need to care for elder family members.

Finally, as could be expected, there were significant differences in the importance and value of emerging financial services when viewed from an income perspective. 

Revenue Optimization of Emerging Financial Services


As opposed to offering each of these services as part of a menu of individual options a customer can select from, Market Rates Insight found that the bundling of multiple services into logical combinations increased the value potential for banks and credit unions. Obviously, there are many different combinations of services possible, but MRI found that the principle of diminishing returns applies to the bundling of financial services.

Dan Geller states, "The principle of diminishing returns states that demand for services is curved and that any additional consumption beyond the highest point in the curve produces less return. In the case of financial services, the recurring monthly fee consumers are willing to pay for a bundle of services usually begins to diminish after an average of about three combined services."

Interestingly, the optimal point of fee revenue typically occurred before the highest fee-revenue point on the curve.

As a point of illustration, one of the 26 bundles developed by MRI provided the highest fee revenue when low balance alerts, identity theft services, mobile photo bill payment, location-based couponing, eldercare services and payment protection were combined for a total monthly fee of $10.20. 

However, the optimal fee-revenue occurs after bundling only the first three services - low balance alerts, identity theft services and mobile bill payment - for an optimal monthly fee of $8.68. The incremental fee revenue beyond this point begins to diminish significantly, without enough revenue to cover the cost of providing the additional services.


Overall Monthly Fee Income From Bundled Service Package #26
Incremental and Optimal Fee Income From Bundled Service Package #26

Another argument in support of optimizing the service bundle combinations is that many consumers are willing to pay a higher overall monthly fee for the optimal bundle than they would for each service separately. 

For instance, in the above case, study respondents indicated they would pay an average of $2.71 for identity theft services, $2.53 for mobile photo bill pay and $2.43 for low balance alerts. The total fee for these services would be $7.67 individually, while the consumer would pay $8.68 for the optimized bundle - a premium of $1.01 or 13%.

The study provides strong support for the logic of service fee optimization. Twenty-six bundles are featured in the study, with each bundle consisting of an average of three services for an average fee revenue potential of $10.12 per month. When you take into account another finding in the study that 68% of consumers desire these services, an institution can generate an average of about $120 annually in recurring fees from two-thirds of its customer base.


Mission for Financial Marketers and Product Managers


As an industry, we have gotten gun shy around fees due to consumer backlash regarding checking account fees and related services over the past several years. MRI studied bundling this year because in 2012 they found that FIs were giving away too many services for free. According to Rick Barham, CEO and founder of Market Rates Insight, "Our experience told us that it’s very difficult to go from “free to fee” without adding value, and we believed that the best way make this leap was via bundling “free” with other services. Our Study indicates our assumptions were right, and consumers do place importance and value on bundles that support their lifestyles."

This timely study from MRI shows that banks and credit unions no longer need to cower when trying to increase non-interest income. In fact, there are many emerging financial services consumers are willing to pay for either individually or when associated with service bundles.

Conservatively speaking, the study illustrates that institutions who focus on providing valuable services to consumers can generate as much as $10 per month from up to two thirds of the customer base. The key is to use the study results to match data to individual customer segments and to place revenue generation high on the list of strategic priorities for 2013, 2014 and beyond.

Now is the time for financial marketers and product managers to work together to determine the best way to move away from being a utilitarian organization, offering all new services for free to a value focused organization that is willing to assess a fee for value added services.

Find Out More


There’s a lot more to the new 'Growth and Revenue Potential of Emerging Financial Services' study that can't be covered adequately in this blog such as the breakout of results by institution type, the 26 online optimization reports and the competitive analysis, which shows how top financial institutions are integrating these services. In total, there are more than 250 illustrations in the report with high levels of detail that would be valuable to financial marketers and product developers.

Feel free to access the report with the link below. The author of the report, Dan Geller, has also offered to answer questions from my readers about the report by email at dan.geller@marketratesinsight.com.



Additional Insights





Mobile Deposits Boom Means More Money For Banks - Market Rates Insight Blog (July 2013)

The 2013 ath Power Mobile Banking Study - ath Power Consulting (June 2013)

Fee Revenue Optimization Analysis - Market Rates Insight (July 2013)

Subscribe to Bank Marketing Strategy Via Email